No matter where you are, Orthodoxy is unconsciousness

Vice President Joe Biden has apparently starting doing standup comedy.  During his recent visit to China, he urged Chinese youths to “challenge the status quo” and “break the mold of what was old,” because in America we “breathe free” because of our “inherent rejection of orthodoxy.”  After I did a double-take reading that, I wondered: What orthodoxy is he talking about?  Is it the sacred truth that the invisible hand of the market solves all social problems?  Is it the time-honored practice of taxing the working poor and not corporations?   Or the idea that we need to spend half of our nation’s wealth on war and weapons–like the drone that killed a two year old boy in Afghanistan last week?  We don’t breathe free here–we ingest the toxic fumes of nationalist piety and absolute certainty.  Years ago, when I was living and teaching in the Slovak Republic, I was talking to some students, who had only recently been living under a communist regime.  “What’s it like,” I asked them, “to watch the news knowing it’s all lies?” They said, “The only difference between us and you, is that when we watch the news we know it’s bullshit.”  For Americans, as George Orwell wrote in 1984, orthodoxy doesn’t mean thinking a certain way about the world, it “means not thinking–not needing to think. Orthodoxy is unconsciousness.”

The antidote?  Philosophy–which is a fancy name for what Sam Keen calls “living the questions.”  I teach philosophy to high school students, the same age as the youths Joe Biden admonished in China.  And I find that here as well as there, our young people are schooled (coerced) into leaving questions unasked and acquiring ready-made answers that benefit those in power.  This vulnerable moment is the turning point for many, many people.  Whether they go to college or not, they’ve mostly decided on their worldviews by the time they graduate high school.  And those worldviews, by and large, are not their own but those of authority, the “mold of the old,” as Biden put it.  There’s a reason why philosophy is not one of the “core” subjects in our schools.  Because if it were, students would learn very quickly that they didn’t have to put up with an unjust system that incarcerates more of its people than any nation on earth.  They would learn that wars are not noble sacrifices for just causes, but seedy, murderous scrambles for power and resources.  They would learn that the world is the way it is because we let it happen and that we have the responsibility and the power to change it.  They would, in short, learn what it means to be free.


4 thoughts on “No matter where you are, Orthodoxy is unconsciousness

  1. Dr. Graham,

    I couldn’t agree more with this article.

    One of the most challenging things about teaching the youth of China is that they never asked why nor knew how to ask the question.

    They would just respond, “No why”. No critical thinking skills, nada, zip, zilch.

    Although the American education is structured differently in delivering education to the youth, it is just as censored and regurgitated bullshit as what the Chinese youth receive (Seriously!).

    We need more educators like yourself that actually make the students question the information the are reading and recieving and to develop critical thinking skills for use in life.

    Your high school classes were some of the most thought provoking discussions I have had yet and can’t thank you enough for the invaluable information.

    -Alyssa B.

    • Thanks Alyssa–I was at a meeting at a certain place we both know well, listening to people talk about the Chinese educational system. Folks were aghast when told that Chinese art students copied pictures of bamboo, all attempting to draw the same way. Considering that’s how illustrators learn to draw–eventually you get a style, but first you learn by copying very carefully–I didn’t understand why people were shocked. I’m sure we could learn as much from them as they can from us. I read this interesting book about this very topic:

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s